the chick flick guy: a real man with a reel weakness
  • Home
  • Find a Movie
    • A-C
    • D-G
    • H-M
    • N-S
    • T-Z, Numerals
  • Contact the guy

"Puccini for Beginners" ✰✰ Same-sex in the city

01/31/2012

1 Comment

 

Puccini For Beginners - Trailer
Get More: Puccini For Beginners - Trailer

What would Cynthia Nixon think about this film? Nixon, you may recall, was a star of "Sex and the City," a show that I failed to find much charm in. What little I saw of it seemed too mean. But that's irrelevant.

Recently, Nixon was quoted as saying being gay was a choice; that she'd been gay and straight, and gay was better. In "Puccini for Beginners" (2005), some of the characters have the same "choice." Even as the main character falls for a guy, she keeps reminding him that she's really a lesbian. Two other women in the movie have trouble with this "choice," with differing results. Wisely, the movie doesn't suggest its characters are making a decision about gay v. straight. Their choices are personal -- about loving particular individuals -- rather than abstractions about sexual identity.

That's not all that makes me want to like this film. Here are a couple of other things it had going for it:
1. Julianne Nicholson, who I've just discovered. (See "Little Black Book" Review.) Now I've also discovered her limitations. She's not awful in this film, just not great.
2. Smart characters. They haunt bookstores, where they buy things like Dante's "The Inferno" and poetry by Stanley Kunitz. Knowing Kunitz was U.S. Poet Laureate twice is kind of like knowing who played third base for the 1969 Mets. It's good trivia ... if you're into that particular realm. I am, although I wouldn't pay as much attention to Kunitz if I hadn't known his daughter first.

Read More
1 Comment
 

Five football movies to watch instead of the Super Bowl

01/29/2012

3 Comments

 
Picture
Quinton Aaron and Sandra Bullock in "The Blind Side."
The great thing about great sports movies is that -- unlike watching the Super Bowl -- you don't have to understand what takes place on the field. You don't even need to know who's playing. Take last year's "Moneyball." If you went to the theaters expecting to see some great baseball, forget it. It was a great movie about what goes on behind the scenes in Major League Baseball. What was the team? Who cares? Brad Pitt plays the lead. (Psst, it was the Oakland A's.)

So, although I will be watching this year's Super Bowl with my friends, I'd like to offer up a way to participate for those who don't like the game. Here are five football films to give you something else you can do. Put in your rental requests now to be ready for Sunday.

"The Blind Side" (2009) -- The touching core of this film is presented in a humorous way. It's when perfectly made up, coiffed and manicured Leigh Anne Tuohy (Sandra Bullock) stomps onto the field and explains to Michael Oher (Quinton Aaron) that football is all about protecting his family. There's no one tougher on the field than Oher, but there's no one tougher about family than Tuohy. There are good laughs and several tear-worthy scenes in the film. In particular you have to like the bit at the end when Oher strips away his momma's tough shell for a moment. Bullock deserved her Oscar.

"Jerry Maguire" (1996) -- The morals to the story here have to do with loyalty and honesty, though it clearly doesn't hurt to be a darn good football player, either. The Maguire movie has some memorable quotes at its most frenzied and most tender moments. "Show me the money." "You complete me." "You had me at hello." People may remember Tom Cruise and Renée Zellweger, but it was Cuba Gooding Jr. who won the Oscar -- a darn good supporting actor playing a darn good football player.

"Brian's Song" (1971) -- I'm making and exception to my rule about focusing on movies from after 1980 because "Brian's Song" is exceptional. Not many made-for-TV movies are great enough to go from free viewing to the theaters, but this one did. And it inspired a remake in 2001, which is another excuse. I mean, another good reason. The film is based on the true story of football great Gale Sayers and his friendship with Brian Piccolo, dying of cancer. Yes, it's sad. By the way, the Baltimore (not Indiannapolis) Colts beat the Dallas Cowboys in the Super Bowl the year this came out. 

"Little Giants" (1994) -- A minor classic, or maybe I should say a pee wee classic, since that's what it's about, pee wee football. The football is just a new backdrop for an old concept: a group of misfits taking on the best. Head misfit: Rick Moranis. Added bonus, a sexual equity subplot, with a girl as the key to winning the big game. That was important to me as a dad 15 years ago, when my daughter was a budding athlete. We watched "Little Giants" a lot. Shawna Waldron was good as Becky "Icebox" O'Shea, and later good as the daughter in "The American President," but apparently hasn't done much notable since.

"Valentine's Day" (2011) -- OK, I'm cheating on this, but if you want an airy rom com with only a hint of football, this isn't a bad choice. Eric Dane plays Sean Jackson, a professional football player who is making a big announcement on Valentine's Day that looks like it may be retirement ... but it isn't. Plenty of fluffy romantic plots going on around this, so keep your eyes open or you might miss the big announcement and the surprise of who Jackson's Valentine is.

3 Comments
 

"Little Black Book" ✰✰✰ And then he got shot

01/27/2012

1 Comment

 
Picture
Brittany Murphy and Julianne Nicholson.
Oh, my. I actually quite liked "Little Black Book" (2004), even though it's a Brittany Murphy movie. That's not supposed to happen. It's not as if it's  "Clueless,"  where she played the most annoying supporting character in a great film. Here Murphy has the lead role, and I didn't think she had a license to be a leading lady in a decent film. Exhibit A: "Ramen Girl," her bizarre 2008 Americanization of a fine Japanese film, "Tampopo." "Little Black Book" is somewhere between "Clueless" and  "Ramen Girl."

It has small amounts of the weaknesses that can cripple romantic comedies. Here and there are predictable happenings and situations that stretch credulity -- the two opposite qualities that always seem to co-exist in the bad rom coms. The trite and the unbelievable do not make for a good combination. And it has too many good looking people. I suffered.

"Little Black Book" also  breaks the taboo against joking about the dead, but I liked it. Toward the end of the film,  Murphy's disappointed-in-love character, Stacy, is reminded that John Lennon said life is what happens when you're making other plans. "And then he got shot," Stacy retorts. 

Stacy is good woman with a good boyfriend, but she fouls it up by going through his Palm Pilot -- pre-iPhone -- and researching his ex-girlfriends. She works for one of those horrible embarrass-the-guest reality talk shows (with Kathy Bates as the host), and uses the show as a pretext for her research. It all comes back to Jerry Springer her in the end.

The plot works better than it sounds.  The story has heart and, better still, is brave enough to break that heart without artificially patching things up. Stacy bonds with one of her beau's exes, played by Julianne Nicholson. Nicholson's face won me over. When Stacy's betrayals are revealed, the pain feels real in both their faces. The resulting losses are what the "life happens" lecture is about.

Just when Stacy is most bereft, the movie gives her new hope, and then yanks it away again. What? No happily ever after? Comedy in the classic sense demands that she gets some kind of reward in the end. She does, but it's not a romantic reward. There is also a cameo appearance in the last scene, but it's not quite who we've been led to expect throughout the film. As an audience, it can be fun to be misled like that, not  to be misled as happens to the characters in this movie.

It's not fun to be misled about the quality of the movie, either. I don't want you to think it's great, it's not. But for those of us who enjoy the catharsis of cinema love, it's a fun one and Brittany Murphy does a great job.

And then she OD'd. (Hey, if the movie can joke about tragedy, so can I.)

1 Comment
 

"The Lives of Others" ✰✰✰✰

01/26/2012

0 Comments

 
Picture
"The LIves of Others" (2006) definitely isn't one of those cheery, air-headed films I generally prefer, but it is a terrific movie, an Oscar winner, in fact.

The characters at the center of this German film are Georg Dreyman and Christa-Maria Sieland, a prospering playwright and a well-known actress who are lovers. Their solid affection is gradually fractured by pressures from the outside. This is East Berlin, before the Wall fell, and while Sieland feels compelled to compromise for career, Dreyman is dragged by conscience toward conflict with authorities.

That's plenty for a rich, tragic look at love, duty and betrayal. But wait, there's more. The dramatic artists have an audience: Captain Gerd Wiesler, an agent of the Stasi, the secret police charged with knowing everything that goes on and rooting out disloyalty. Wiesler's Stasi superiors sometimes come across as evil clichés, instead of the flawed humans, but that's my only quibble with this film.

Wiesler, early on, also looks like one of those stock German villains -- a by-the-book, heartless cog in the state machinery that crushes lives. That crushing role is echoed rather literally, and ironically, by the fragment of Dreyman's play, shown twice during the film. The play is meant to be anti-capitalist, rather than anti-authoritarian, but it's more universal. Wiesler, meanwhile, is gradually humanized by his own loneliness. To see him after a liaison with a prostitute is like seeing a small boy left alone after his mother leaves. Wiesler's weakness allows a tiny foothold for him to develope dangerous sympathy for the lovers as he eavesdrops on them, knowing the secrets they can't tell each other.

This is tragedy in a classic sense, with small faults of character and events leading inevitably to the downfall of the three main characters. It is redeemed at the very end with a somewhat artificial but pleasing act of forgiveness. 

It's worth noting that Sieland is played by Martina Gedeck, who played the lead in one of my favorite romantic comedies,  "Mostly Martha." Dreyman is played by Sebastian Koch, who is in the chilling Dutch film "Black Book" as a Nazi. Both films have a theme of sleeping with the enemy, but Koch is victim in one, bad guy in the other.

Add Comment
 

"Tamara Drewe" ✰✰✰✰ It's not always about Drewe

01/24/2012

3 Comments

 
Picture
Tamara Drewe - The graphic novel and the movie.
What if "Jerry Maguire" wasn't about Jerry Maguire, "Michael Clayton" not about Michael Clayton or "Erin Brockovich" not about  "Erin Brockovich?" 

Those wouldn't make sense, but one of the great things about "Tamara Drewe" (2010) is that it isn't all about her. Sure, she's a fine character - an attractive, young London journalist, returned to the country home of her mother. She is much changed, thanks to a nose job, and not just in her appearnce. But showing up again stirs up the countryside. Even the handsome but taciturn handy Andy Cobb gets his Wellingtons in a state over her.

Picture
Jody (Jessica Barden) and her pal Casey.
Through Drewe is a big piece of the movie named for her, other characters make claims that the story is theirs. There is Cobb, who yearns for Tamara and the ancestral home that his family lost. Glen is the American scholar who has lost confidence in his writing and his ability to love. Beth is the woman who coddles her unfaithful husband and keeps Stonefield -- their farm and writers' retreat -- running. Nicholas is the philandering husband, a writer of popular mysteries. And there are others.

My favorite, truly, is the 15-year-old village girl. Angry about how she and her mother were abandoned by her  father and bored out of her adolescent mind, Jody says nearly everything with a sneer, even when dreaming aloud of shagging rock star, teen magazine idol Ben Sergeant.. She may sound dreadful, but I found her hilarious. Freckled actress Jessica Barden steals multiple scenes as Jody and blusters her way into my heart and, eventually, finds a way into her idol's arms -- though maybe not in the way she imagined.


Read More
3 Comments
 

Coming attractions. And going concerns.

01/23/2012

0 Comments

 
Picture
"Tamara Drewe," the (ahem) cheeky British comedy.
Here's a look at what's planned for the Chick Flick Guy in the next week or so, and what you might have missed if you didn't check in during the past week. First, what's on tap:
"Tamara Drewe" - A cheeky English comedy of romance. Cheeky, if for nothing else than Gemma Arterton's short shorts. In the United Kingdom are they called Daisy UKes?
"The Lives of Others" - From the dark days of divided Berlin comes a great story of love, betrayal and sympathy. Definitely ot a rom com.
"Little Black Book" - I expected this Brittany Murphy film to be bad, bad, bad. It turned out to be pretty entertaining.
Football for Football Widows - A list of films with football themes, for folks who want to something different to watch during the Super Bowl.

And then, here's what we ran in the past week:
10 Movie Quotes So Famous, You Know Them Without Seeing the Film -- A Quiz
"The Night We Never Met" -- A review of the so-so Matthew Broderick film.
"Eat Pray Love" -- Modestly entertaining, well made, forgettable. (Except to those who found the main character self-indulgent.)
Movie Blog Watch -- A look at another good rom com blog you might want to check out.
Throw out the Tradition, Not the Flowers -- A look at 11 movies that include a bouquet toss. And a wedding, of course.

Add Comment
 

Throw out that tradition, not the flowers - 11 movies with a wedding bouquet toss

01/22/2012

0 Comments

 
Picture
The bouquet toss that kicks off the "Bride Wars."
I've gone soft on traditions as I've matured. (Matured. That's the nice way to say I'm getting old.) Many traditions are empty actions carried out unthinkingly -- sometimes as holdovers of long-lost superstitions. Others, however, still have the potential to carry meaning -- as long as we take the time to think about them . Those traditions link us to times past and to others who share them. That's not such a bad thing. Innovation is wonderful, especially in art and science, but storytelling -- especially in romantic comedies -- leans on conventions that audiences will recognize and know how to interpret. That's why we're still watching "Romeo and Juliet" all these centuries later.

But that doesn't explain the wedding bouquet toss. Do you know why it's done? It began as a symbol of sharing the good luck of marriage. It has become something of an ugly spectacle -- especially when interpreted as a competition between desperate single women, who are so needy for a man that they'd fight over that good luck symbol. (Whereas men, who are more rational, would never fight over anything purely symbolic. We're too busy fighting over stuff that matters, like football and parking spaces.)

I could do without the bouquet toss. I cannot  remember witnessing a bouquet toss in any of the weddings I've attended over the years, but it shows up on a regular basis in movies. Given that we've had a film based around a wedding singer and a wedding planner, I wonder when someone's going to build a rom com around the wedding bouquet. (Tina Fey, if you want to borrow my idea, go ahead.) Everyone else, read more to see my list of some movies that attempt to use the bouquet toss for a momentary angle, albeit often a bad one.


Read More
Add Comment
 

Movie Blog Watch - For rom com fans, and writers

01/21/2012

4 Comments

 
Here's a brilliant blog that you might like: Living the Romantic Comedy.

In fact, if you like the Chick Flick Guy, you might like Living the Romantic Comedy even more and switch your blog loyalties. Blogger Billy Mernit, like CFG, spends a lot of time finding common threads among seemingly disparate movies and writing about them. He knows his stuff and and is a sharp writer. While CFG likes lists with a little explanation, Mernit goes into a bit deeper analysis, often with erudite references. CFG may have the edge on humor. Maybe.

Mernit's most recent piece was "Rethinking the Happy Ending," an analysis of what audiences like in the happy ending. It isn't the resolution that captures audiences, he says, so much as the sharing of that happiness with others. He could be right. It certainly fits with "The Descendants," a recent movie he didn't cite. I've heard more than one person say that what they loved best was the final scene of "The Descendants." It's a scene that with no catharsis, no resolution, no drama, no dialogue even -- just three people watching television and sharing ice cream.

Another post that caught my eye was a piece titled Archetypes: The Manic Pixie Dream Girl, which touches on a few of my favorite films, "Elizabethtown," "Garden State" and "(500) Days of Summer."

Mernit's blog is less about reviews, more a tool for would-be screenwriters looking at what works. In fact, he's also written a book on writing romantic comedies. As I said, he knows his stuff, even if I dislike some of the movies he applauds. If you visit his blog, let him know who sent you.
4 Comments
 

"Eat Pray Love" ✰✰✰ - Seen Enjoyed Forgotten (mostly)

01/20/2012

0 Comments

 
Picture
The "airport book" I bought but have not yet read.
There's one brief scene in "Eat Pray Love" (2010) that immediately imprinted itself on me, but if you've seen the film I'm guessing you won't remember it. As Liz Gilbert (Julia Roberts) arrives at her ashram in India to begin the movie's second act, her taxi is seen driving up to the entrance from an upstairs vantage point. For an instant -- maybe a second, at most -- the outline of the taxi is perfectly aligned in the building's arch, which mimics the taxi's shape. The symmetry is there for a moment, and then gone, but I'm sure someone put a lot of effort into that one second out of nearly 8,000 seconds in the movie -- getting the vantage point, making sure the taxi stopped in the perfect spot when it rolled up. And then it's gone.

Which is a little bit how this movie is for me. It's an enormous production made in mulitple countries. I can only begin to imagine the required logistics to have lighting, equipment, personnel, permissions, etc. Let alone whatever's required to make sure Ms. Roberts' and Mr. Javier Bardem's trailers were properly cooled and stocked with the proper flavor of energy water with electrolytes. And now that I've watched it, it's pretty much gone for me. Or at least it will be once I post this review

The movie makers' work pays off with a film that seems -- as far as I can see -- faultlessly produced and acted. I don't think anyone is better than Roberts at simulating a variety of smiles -- joyous, fearful, tender and, my favorite, the smile that is supposed to look fake. You know, when someone feels they have to smile, is faking it. She's as good at faking a real fake smile as anyone around.


Read More
Add Comment
 

"The Night We Never Met" ✰✰✰ - Beating on a tea kettle

01/19/2012

0 Comments

 
An academic I saw on television this week said children's shows in the 1990s always had the smart kid as an outsider -- respected perhaps, but not cool. Nowadays, she said, the nerd is the cool one while the outsider role is someone with an artsy streak. Of course, the person saying that nerds are now cool was herself a certifiable nerd - a Jeopardy contestant - so there might be questions about whether her conclusions were unbiased.

In any case, movies are, like the rest of pop culture, subject to streaks, trends and fads in how they treat people and situations.

Watching "The Night We Never Met" (1993), what I noticed most was how it diverges from what might be seen as a current trend. Three recent movies I liked -- "The Descendants," "Crazy, Stupid, Love" and "The Kids Are All Right" -- all seem to treat infidelity as a problem, a real problem. At the end of these three films, the characters we care about are still in pain because of betrayal, even though some things have been patched up.

It might seem obvious (except to Newt Gingrich) that spousal inconstancy could lead to negative complications, but movies -- especially romantic comedies -- don't always see it that way. In the 1990s, I saw a lot of movies where heretofore dedicated relationships had to end in order for the real happiness to take place. "Sleepless in Seattle" and "You've Got Mail" are examples.

Read More
Add Comment
 
<< Previous

    The Chick Flick Guy

    Chick Flick Guy says no thanks to Shoot, Crash and Explode Cinema. (Except "Speed.") He's the man sitting alone in theaters where the audience is mostly couples and Girls Night Out groups. This website is where you can find categorized lists of favorite romantic comedies and the occasional weeper, brief reviews and polls asking you what you think about  films and stars, popular and indie. 

    Follow chickflickguy on Twitter

    Categories

    All
    Classics
    Favorites
    Guest Bloggers
    Lists
    Other Movie Blogs
    Previews
    Reader Questions
    Review
    Reviews
    The Guyifesto
    Trivia Questions

    The Banner

    The "Chick Flick Guy" image is made from letters in movie titles. For more on that, click here.

    RSS Feed

    About the guy

    Carlos Alcalá is a middle-aged man with the movie tastes of a
    13-year-old girl. Fortunately, he is also a writer with strong analytical skills and decades of experience. He is married to a woman who has far better taste in cinema and he has three children, including a daughter who finds her father's love of chick flicks embarrassing. 

    Picture

    What the stars mean

    ✰ 
    So bad that it offends. I need to wash my eyes now.
    ✰✰ 
    Can't recommend it, but it has some redeeming qualities.
    ✰✰✰ 
    Average, but I really enjoyed it. I'm like that.
    ✰✰✰✰ 
    Love it. It has flaws, but they're endearing.
    ✰✰✰✰✰ 
    So good, I don't know what to say. Can we watch it again now?

    Archives

    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011


Create a free website with Weebly