the chick flick guy: a real man with a reel weakness
  • Home
  • Find a Movie
    • A-C
    • D-G
    • H-M
    • N-S
    • T-Z, Numerals
  • Contact the guy

"High Fidelity" and the Desert Island, All-Time Top Five Nick Hornby Chick Flicks

09/30/2011

1 Comment

 
Picture
Nick Hornby, the English author of “High Fidelity,” is a guy’s guy. (I would say “a man’s man,” but I’m the Chick Flick Guy.) In all his books – the six or seven I’ve read – Hornby shows he knows the modern chap inside and out. He sees our flaws and sympathizes with our woes.

And yet, his books beg to be turned into chick flicks. Why is that?

It’s because Hornby’s male type specimen is clueless and immature, but ripening on his tree, waiting for life’s storms to blow him into the lap of the right woman.  What Jane Austen did for the well-educated but fiercely independent young woman of the 1800s, Hornby does for the well-intentioned but fiercely uncommitted young dude of our times.

So, in honor of all the lists that glue the “High Fidelity” story together, here’s our list of Hornby books-turned-movies:

1.   High Fidelity  (2000) This is Hornby’s best book and the best movie made from one – despite the fact that the movie transfers the story from England to the United States. John Cusack worked obsessively on the music, picking 70 songs from thousands of options – in the process doing a good version of his music-obsessive character, Rob Gordon. Among the great scenes: an imaginary conversation with Bruce Springsteen, Rob’s reluctance to profit on another’s misery when a wronged wife tries to give him a priceless record collection and Rob's failed effort to duck behind a hedge in the rain – which leads to an odd romantic encounter with his ex. I could talk about this film all day.


Read More
1 Comment
 

Ryan Reynolds - Leading man or Also-ran?

09/29/2011

6 Comments

 
Picture
When he heard about this blog, a co-worker with a teenage daughter told me I had to do something on Ryan Reynolds.

"Who?" I asked, instantly destroying all my credibility.

It turns out I'd recently seen Reynolds - multiple times - in a movie I really like, "Definitely, Maybe," (2008) but his name didn't stick with me. His credits on IMDB look decent, but not standout. He was also in "Adventureland," (2009) but not the lead. That went to a (more likeable than in "The Social Network") Jesse Eisenberg.

So I ask you: Does playing Captain Excellent and Green Lantern really make a leading man, or is Ryan Reynolds an also ran? 

Please vote in the comments.

6 Comments
 

"One Day" (2011) - More Than One Hathaway ✰✰✰✰

09/28/2011

2 Comments

 
Picture
Anne Hathaway has a way of throwing curves – to use a guyish baseball metaphor.

We met her as dorky Mia Thermopolis in “Princess Diaries” and then all of a sudden she was a bawdy rodeo gal in the beautiful love story “Brokeback Mountain.” Goofy Andy Sachs (“The Devil Wears Prada”) gave way to the sobering Maggie Murdock in “Love and Other Drugs.”  

In “One Day,” she’s doing it all in one film.


Read More
2 Comments
 

10 Favorite "I Hate You/I Love You" Movies

09/26/2011

4 Comments

 
Once upon a time, when people acted like they didn’t like each other, it meant they actually didn’t like each other. In the modern romantic comedy, it means they’re going to fall in love. (Although, sometimes when people act like they don't like each other, it's called modern marriage.) 

Every romantic comedy needs an obstacle for its lovers to overcome. What better obstacle could there be than two characters who hate each other? It’s been used successfully since the time of Shakespeare. (In fact, some of these movies are Shakespeare, or derived from Shakespeare.) Love them or hate them, here are 10 movies with antagonist protagonist lovers. Not necessarily the best 10 - "Leap Year" Is one of the worst - but you can add your favorites in the comments.
  1. When Harry Met Sally  (1989)  – Billy Crystal and Meg Ryan.
  2. 10 Things I Hate About You  (1999) - Heath Ledger and Julia Stiles.
  3. Mostly Martha  (2001)  -- Martina Gedeck  and Sergio Castellitto.
  4. You’ve Got Mail (1998)  - Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan. 
  5. Clueless (1995) – Alicia Silverstone and Paul Rudd.
  6. 27 Dresses (2008) - Katherine Heigl and James Marsden
  7. Much Ado About Nothing (1993) – Kenneth Branagh and Emma Thompson
  8. Leap Year (2010) – Amy Adams and Matthew Goode
  9. Sweet Home Alabama (2002) – Reese Witherspoon and Josh Lucas
  10. Life as We Know It (2010) - Katherine Heigl and Josh Duhamel

4 Comments
 

"Moneyball" (2011) - Where's the romance? ✰✰✰✰

09/25/2011

0 Comments

 
Picture
People who assumed it was me dragging my wife to the baseball movie ("Moneyball") last night would've been wrong. She was the Oakland A's fan from back in the '80s. She's the one who wanted to see the film about how Billy Beane changed baseball's approach to buying players , culminating (the movie has it) with the 2004 World Series Champion Boston Red Sox. Me, the Chick Flick Guy, I was a teeny bit disappointed by the lack of romance, especially with Robin Wright in the picture. (From certain perspectives, I hear Brad Pitt's pretty good looking, too.) I did like the little parental-filial love thing between Beane and his daughter, shown at left. It's a well-made, high-quality film, but not really in my strike zone.

Add Comment
 

Trivia: What's the 2009 romantic comedy where characters in LA don't drive?

09/24/2011

0 Comments

 
Q: What great 2009 film, based in the most car-centric big city in America, only shows the main characters driving a private vehicle once? Instead, the characters ride the bus, the train, a bicycle, take taxis and even appear at a subway station entrance - in Los Angeles! Read more for the answer.

Read More
Add Comment
 

"Crazy, Stupid, Love" (2011) - Real love, alongside the slapstick ✰✰✰

09/23/2011

4 Comments

 
“Crazy, Stupid, Love”  puts more bittersweet love and affection than you'd expect into a discussion of lighting the water heater pilot – and more than a lot of films achieve in any scene. (Though some Hallmark commercials come close.)

 I’m sorry to say, the film has too much slapstick (and not enough Emma Stone)  to get a lot of stars from me. Still, the heater scene between Steve Carell  and Julianne Moore shows estranged partners reaching out to each other using a mundane pretext, and is one of several fine moments of emotional reality that elevate the film.

“Crazy, Stupid, Love” also offers this shocking news bulletin:  Romantic infidelity can cause pain. Carell is Cal Weaver, a middle-aged guy trying to solve a Rubik’s cube of relationships after his wife, Moore, reveals she slept with a co-worker. It complicates his relationships with everyone around him – friends, kids, co-workers, babysitter, everyone.

Cheating on or  leaving a boyfriend, girlfriend, spouse or fiancé is down right rom com common, but it  usually leads to happiness, because the character is finding a true soul mate. Examples: “The Wedding Planner,”   “Sleepless in Seattle,”  and “Letters to Juliet.”  I could go on and on. (And will, in a future post.) For now, let’s just say I like the occasional rom com that shows the collateral damage.

Beyond the genuine emotions and an excess of humiliation for Carell's character, there is a lot of fun in this movie, too.

Read More
4 Comments
 

Four Great Movies with John and Joan Cusack

09/22/2011

2 Comments

 
Nobody is going to put John Cusack into a romantic role opposite his sister Joan Cusack -- God, I hope not -- but  they still have great film chemistry. Their phone interactions in “Grosse Pointe Blank” are classic, especially when Marcella (Joan) cradles the phone while she works to burn down their office. The movie is all about John’s hired assassin Martin Blank and Minnie Driver’s Debi Newberry – his too-cool former girlfried - but Joan is a scene stealer when she manifests Jekyll and Hyde phone personalities when switching lines between a weapons dealer and a recipe sharer. Here are the great four:
  1. Grosse Pointe Blank (1997) – Joan plays office manager Marcella for paid assassin Martin Blank (John), convincing the boss to go to his 10-year high school reunion while he’s in Detroit to do a hit. ✰✰✰✰✰
  2. Sixteen Candles (1984) – The Cusacks just have bit parts as geeks in this film and they don't meet onscreen, so you're watching this movie for something else. Still, keep your eyes open for the young siblings and their background appearances in a variety of head gear. ✰✰✰✰
  3. Say Anything (1989)– I don’t want sell anything, buy anything or process anything, but I do want to watch over and over, as John (as Lloyd Dobler) says that phrase in various permutations, trying to win Ione Skye’s Diane Court over and over. John's sister plays (whaddaya know) Lloyd’s sister. ✰✰✰✰✰
  4. High Fidelity (2000)– One of the most successful cases ever of moving a movie setting from one country to another _- in this case moving from the England of Nick Hornby’s amazing book, to the Chicago of John Cusack’s world. John picked the music, including my first intro to the wonderful band Belle and Sebastian. Joan is mostly notable here for chewing John out. ✰✰✰✰✰
I have not yet seen Cradle Will Rock, Martian Child or War, Inc. – three other Cusack & Cusack vehicles. Anyone have words of wisdom about any of those?

2 Comments
 

"Easy A" (2010) - Easily an A ✰✰✰✰✰

09/18/2011

5 Comments

 
“Easy A” doesn’t wear its literary pedigree on its sleeve. Nope, it’s stitched prominently on its revealing bodice. This catchy update of “The Scarlet Letter” never gets tired of reminding you what Great American Novel it's based on, right down to the big, red A on actress Emma Stone’s chest. You can’t miss it really, unless (as sometimes happens) her décolletage distracts your attention. That’s my biggest quibble about “Easy A”: It’s based on the premise that Olive (Stone’s character) was something of an invisible teen until an unseemly rumor about her virginity took flight. Stone, especially with auburn hair, is way too attractive to have been the wallflower. Oh, well. I suffered through the improbability of it all. 

That notwithstanding, I think this is best of the subgenre of classic tales moved to high school – well, the best since “Clueless” set the standard and seemingly spawned the whole genre in 1995. That movie, by the way, never felt compelled  to tell you it was based on a Jane Austen novel, “Emma.”

In “Easy A” we’re in beautiful Ojai (near Santa Barbara), instead of 17th century Salem, so a few changes are necessary. For one thing, those deemed insufficiently virtuous aren’t dunked in a pond. Given how “Easy A” exploits Emma Stone’s, ahem, physical assets, it’s a little surprising they didn’t go for a pond and a wet T-shirt. But instead of pond or pillory, her character Olive gets detention and has to clean the cafeteria and bathroom.

Stone’s Olive casually dumps quirky, offhanded punch lines (like a good episode of “Gilmore Girls”) and moves on.  Stanley Tucci and Patricia Clarkson, as her parents, are the kind of parents are lots of fun onscreen, but can be pretty embarrassing in real life. Still, I love watching them devote their comedic talents to a single letter (T, not Olive’s A), as they try to guess the epithet that got their daughter sent to the principal.

“Easy A” honors its cinematic ancestors, as well as Hawthorne’s novel, referring to and updating classic scenes from “Sixteen Candles,” “The Breakfast Club,” “Say Anything,” “Ferris Bueller’s Day Off” and (huh?) “Can’t Buy Me Love.” It also takes sly digs at Demi Moore’s film version of  “The Scarlet Letter.”


5 Comments
 

Five High School Movies Based on Books Assigned in High School

09/18/2011

0 Comments

 
These five aren't the kind of film I saw in high school. Back then, English teachers showed us movies of "Macbeth," "Fahrenheit 451," and even a cartoon version of "Animal Farm," knowing not everyone was actually going to read the book. Likewise, in “Easy A” (No. 4 below), Thomas Haden Church’s Mr. Griffin is frustrated by modern students who think watching Demi Moore’s “Scarlet Letter” is a passable substitute for reading Hawthorne's classic. 

These movies aren't movie versions of classics, they are reimagined modern versions of classics, each one set in a high school, in order to appeal to tweens, teens and Chick Flick Guys. Students who try to watch any of these as a substitute for classwork are even more clueless than Alicia Silverstone's Cher Horowitz in our first pick. 

  1.  Clueless (1995) – The best of the category. Amy Heckerling’s “Clueless” is so good, it made me read the book it was based on: Jane Austen’s “Emma.” Sharp writing, clever costuming, perfect casting and cheeky social commentary (like Austen's original) make “Clueless” priceless. But you also have to blame this film's success for spawning the lesser updates below. ✰✰✰✰✰
  2.  10 Things I Hate About You (1999) -  Heath Ledger and Julia Stiles play outcasts who are made for each other, if only they can get past those 10 things. It is based, need we say, on Shakespeare’s “Taming of the Shrew,” but has a better soundtrack. I’m tempted to say “Shrew” was the first version of  the I Hate You, I Love You sub-genre. However, knowing that Shakespeare stole many of his plots, I'm not so sure. ✰✰✰✰
  3.   She’s the Man (2006) – Amanda Bynes. How can you enjoy an actor so obnoxious? Actually, I can't, but I can enjoy some of her films. There are a handful of enjoyable moments in this Shakespeare knock-off, where a teen takes her brother's spot in boarding school so she can play soccer. A version of one of Shakespeare's more difficult comedies, “Twelfth Night.” ✰✰✰
  4. Easy A (2010) – Emma Stone’s Olive is no Puritan, but she’s an updated Hester Prynne, right down to the big red A she wears on her significantly-bigger than A-sized chest. Ojai, near Santa Barbara, makes a more picturesque backdrop than Salem, and in high school, the bad kids don't get pilloried or dunked. They have to clean the cafeteria and the bathrooms. ✰✰✰✰✰
  5. She’s All That (1999) – Shaw’s “Pygmalion” is the story of trying to turn raw material into a real woman. So is “My Fair Lady.”  The story is good material to start with -- "My Fair Lady" is the classic update of the classic -- but “She’s All That “ is a substandard version. ✰✰✰

Add Comment
 
<< Previous

    The Chick Flick Guy

    Chick Flick Guy says no thanks to Shoot, Crash and Explode Cinema. (Except "Speed.") He's the man sitting alone in theaters where the audience is mostly couples and Girls Night Out groups. This website is where you can find categorized lists of favorite romantic comedies and the occasional weeper, brief reviews and polls asking you what you think about  films and stars, popular and indie. 

    Follow chickflickguy on Twitter

    Categories

    All
    Classics
    Favorites
    Guest Bloggers
    Lists
    Other Movie Blogs
    Previews
    Reader Questions
    Review
    Reviews
    The Guyifesto
    Trivia Questions

    The Banner

    The "Chick Flick Guy" image is made from letters in movie titles. For more on that, click here.

    RSS Feed

    About the guy

    Carlos Alcalá is a middle-aged man with the movie tastes of a
    13-year-old girl. Fortunately, he is also a writer with strong analytical skills and decades of experience. He is married to a woman who has far better taste in cinema and he has three children, including a daughter who finds her father's love of chick flicks embarrassing. 

    Picture

    What the stars mean

    ✰ 
    So bad that it offends. I need to wash my eyes now.
    ✰✰ 
    Can't recommend it, but it has some redeeming qualities.
    ✰✰✰ 
    Average, but I really enjoyed it. I'm like that.
    ✰✰✰✰ 
    Love it. It has flaws, but they're endearing.
    ✰✰✰✰✰ 
    So good, I don't know what to say. Can we watch it again now?

    Archives

    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011


Create a free website with Weebly